STATEMENT OF NBI DIRECTOR MELVIN A. MATIBAG
On the request for inhibition by counsel for Rep. Paolo Duterte


STATEMENT OF NBI DIRECTOR MELVIN A. MATIBAG
On the request for inhibition by counsel for Rep. Paolo Duterte


The NBI has received the letter of Rep. Paolo Duterte’s counsel asking the Bureau and its Director to stop investigating the allegations of Rodulfo M. Gracioso Jr. The request has no basis in law, and the investigation continues.

Inhibition, and the “cold neutrality” counsel invokes, are standards for those who judge. The NBI does not judge. It establishes facts. Whether there is probable cause is for the prosecutor or the Ombudsman to decide, and should the matter reach that stage, Rep. Duterte will have every opportunity to answer there. The law gives the Bureau the authority to investigate, and no law requires it to set that authority aside.

A polygraph result is an examiner’s reading of whether a person shows signs of deception. It speaks to the witness, not to the facts. It is not proof, courts do not treat it as such, and it is not a finding on anyone’s guilt. The Bureau has made no such finding. Every allegation is being tested against documents, records and testimony.

Rep. Duterte has been denied nothing the law gives him at this stage. He has had the affidavit since October 5, and the Bureau’s invitation to give his side stands. The formal right to answer the evidence belongs to the preliminary investigation, should one be conducted.

The columns counsel cites were written in 2024 before I assumed as NBI Director and are matters of public concern, and I disclosed them openly under oath. They bear on no fact in Mr. Gracioso’s affidavit, and no finding of the Bureau will rest on anything but evidence.

The comparison with the Davao City prosecutor does not hold. That prosecutor was to rule on a complaint, and he is a first cousin of the former President’s partner. That is a specific family relationship of the kind the rules recognize. Applying the same principle means applying it to the same role.

The NBI will follow the evidence and submit its findings to the proper authority.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *